Federal News
Supreme Court Ends Cocaine Dealers' Legal Limbo
By Timothy M. Phelps, Los Angeles Times
The Supreme Court threw a lifeline to thousands of convicted cocaine dealers who were on the edge of what the justices called a sentencing cliff.
In a 5-4 ruling, the court said the Fair Sentencing Act, which relaxed mandatory prison sentences for crack cocaine dealers, covers people who were charged but not yet sentenced when the act became law in 2010.
One of the few times recently when Congress has shortened rather than lengthened sentences, the act passed with bipartisan support to eliminate a stark disparity between the required sentences for powder cocaine sellers, who are often white, and those who sell crack cocaine, who are disproportionally black.
Cocaine traffickers were dealt with much more leniently than those who sold crack. One gram of crack cocaine was treated as equal to 100 grams of powder cocaine.
Congress did not specify whether the change should be retroactive, but JusticeStephen G. Breyer, who wrote the majority opinion for the court, said Thursday that not making the act retroactive to those charged but not yet sentenced would "preserve a disproportionate status quo" and "create new anomalies." He concluded that it would create "a new disparate sentencing cliff."
Breyer said that not applying the act to those already in the legal system when the act was passed "would produce a crazy quilt of sentences, at odds with Congress' basic efforts to achieve more uniform, more proportionate sentences." He said that Congress "could not have intended any such result."
Before the court were the cases of two Illinois men who found themselves in great legal jeopardy because of the dates of their crimes.
Corey Hill sold 53 grams of crack to an informant in 2007. In December 2010, a federal judge in Chicago sentenced him to 10 years in prison, instead of the roughly four years he would have gotten under the law that had passed four months earlier.
Edward Dorsey was caught selling 5.5 grams of crack at a motel in Kankakee, Ill. One month after the law was signed, he was also sentenced to a mandatory minimum 10 years because of a previous drug felony. Under the new law, he would not have been subject to a minimum sentence.
Joining Breyer and the other more liberal justices was Justice Anthony M. Kennedy.
In a dissent, Justice Antonin Scalia agreed with Breyer that ignoring the change in the law for those charged but not yet sentenced "leads to a series of cliffs." But he concluded, "This does not establish that Congress clearly meant the new mandatory minimums to apply to pre-enactment offenders."
(c)2012 the Los Angeles Times
If you enjoyed this post, subscribe for updates.
- Most Viewed
- Comments
-
- Congress Passes Highway, Transit Bill
"$util.encode.html($string.substring($comment.comment,0,$space))..." - Obama Proposes $75 Billion for Universal Preschool
"There are numerous studies from decades of research of early childhood education that..."
- Congress Passes Highway, Transit Bill
Latest from Federal News
- Connecticut's Landmark Gun Law Faces Court Challenge
- A coalition of gun owners, gun dealers and firearms rights organizations have sued the governor and members of the state's attorney's office, contending that the gun law passed in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shootings violates the Constitution.
- Border-State Governors Call for More Security
- Advances in technology like drones, fences and surveillance cameras are playing a prominent role in the immigration debate. Some argue they've made the border more secure than ever, but governors in border states say the work is far from done.
- Arizona's 20-Week Abortion Ban Struck Down
- Arizona is likely to appeal the ruling and may ask the nation's high court to re-examine the right to abortion, established in the 1973 Roe vs. Wade decision.
- Supreme Court to Reexamine Church-State Separation at Government Meetings
- The Supreme Court has agreed to revisit the issue of church-state separation and decide whether a town council can begin most of its monthly meetings with a prayer from a Christian pastor.
- Obama Declares Oklahoma Tornado a Major Disaster
- At least 51 people were killed when a massive tornado blasted through central Oklahoma, flattening neighborhoods and destroying two elementary schools. The grim work of search, rescue and recovery continues today.
GOVERNING Data
- U.S. City Population Map: 1990-2012
- View an interactive map with updated figures for cities with populations exceeding 50,000.
- Average Hospital Cost By State
- Youth Unemployment Rate, Figures by State
- U.S. County Population Change Map: 2010-2012
- International Migration: U.S. Cities and Metro Area Populations
- Same Sex Marriage Map: State Laws
Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn
YouTube
Flickr
RSS
© 2011 e.Republic, Inc. All Rights reserved. |