Judge: Florida's Attempt to Privatize Prison Health Care Violated Law
A state judge struck down an attempt by the Florida Legislature to privatize prison health care by using a budgetary process instead of making the change through a full vote of lawmakers.
For the second time in over a year, a state judge has ruled that the Florida Legislature violated the law when it tried to privatize the state's role in operating prisons.
Leon County Circuit Court Judge John Cooper on Tuesday struck down an attempt by the Florida Legislature to privatize prison health care by using a budgetary process instead of making the change through a full vote of lawmakers.
Gov. Rick Scott and the Department of Corrections said they will appeal the ruling, warning that the state now faces a $90 million deficit because they had counted saving that much over the next two years by having private contractors provide prison health care.
Cooper said that the Legislature had the power to contract its prison health services to private, for-profit companies, but it went about it the wrong way. Rather than put the issue up for a full vote -- and face likely defeat -- legislative leaders chose to rely on the 14-member Legislative Budget Commission to authorize the change during its September meeting.
"While the State of Florida does have authority to privatize prison health care throughout the state, the full Legislature must do so by passing the appropriate funding mechanism specifically directed to that goal,'' Cooper wrote in his 12-page ruling. "Authorizing and funding privatizing health services in Florida's prisons is the prerogative of the full Legislature and not that of the Legislative Budget Commission."
The ruling is the second rebuke to legislative leaders in just over a year as they have struggled to usher in prison privatization without putting the controversial concept to a full vote. Unions and legislators from rural counties, where the prison industry is strong, have been the most vocal opponents.
In October 2011, Leon County Judge Jackie Fulford ruled unconstitutional an attempt to privatize prisons in 18 South Florida counties after legislators tucked the provision in budget proviso language and failed to use a separate bill.
Faced with the court's slap down, the Florida Senate returned with a bill in February 2012, but it failed on a 21-9 vote as nine Republicans joined with Democrats.
Rather than force another difficult vote, legislative leaders included a line item in the 2012-13 budget authorizing the privatization of the prison health care system for only the South Florida region. A contract with Wexford Health System is pending approval for that program.
Legislative leaders then waited until the September meeting of the Legislative Budget Commission to propose an amendment that would expand the program from just South Florida to the rest of the state. The LBC adopted a budget amendment that allowed for a $259 million contract to hire Nashville-based Corizon Correctional Health Care to handle prison health care in regions I, II and III.
Cooper ruled the Corizon contract was invalid because it was not authorized by the Legislature and did not fall under the requirement that amendments by the LBC be "limited" adjustments to the budget.
"Whether to privatize some of all of this state's prison operations is a significant policy decision,'' Cooper wrote. "..."It is the duty of the full legislature, not a small group of select legislators to make policy decisions on spending.''
He said the law requires that changes to the budget approved by the LBC follow the legislature's intent "not new policy/spending priority decisions that could have been but were not passed by the full legislature. Otherwise, the exception swallows the rule, allowing a small handful of legislators He said the law requires that changes to the budget approved by the LBC follow the legislature's intent "not new policy/spending priority decisions that could have been but were not passed by the full legislature. Otherwise, the exception swallows the rule, allowing a small handful of legislators to rewrite the [budget.]"
The unions will seek an injunction asking the court to immediately order the state to halt the contracts, said Alma Gonzalez, lawyer for AFSCME.
The ruling could have precedent-setting implications for future budget decisions, she said.
(c)2012 The Miami Herald
We invite you to discuss and comment on this article using social media.