Internet Explorer 11 is not supported

For optimal browsing, we recommend Chrome, Firefox or Safari browsers.

Are Republican States More Federally Dependent?

A new report reveals the great variation of federal dependency across the states. But drawing the line between federal and state responsibility is not easy.

a sign at a retailer that says We Accept SNAP in Muncie, Indiana - January 2018
(Jonathan Weiss/Shutterstock)
Jonathan Weiss
Leading up to the coronavirus pandemic, there was a stigma against federal assistance programs and other federal “handouts.” However, COVID-19 crushed the “fiscal independence” of many states and millions of Americans now depend upon federally assisted unemployment benefit payments, small business support and stimulus checks to endure the economic shutdowns.

The first round of stimulus relief funneled $150 billion in relief to states, while the second round passed in December 2020, didn’t provide any direct payments. For the American Rescue Plan Act, passed in March, states will receive $195 billion in payments. Yet some states will receive far more than others. A new report from WalletHub reveals to what extent each state is reliant upon the federal government for assistance, and which states are more self-sufficient.



Source: WalletHub

WalletHub compared all 50 states across two key dimensions: State Residents’ Dependency and State Government’s Dependency. Each dimension was evaluated by three metrics, which were each weighted through a double 50-point-based system. Within State Residents’ Dependency, return on taxes paid to the federal government was worth 37.5 points and share of federal jobs was worth 12.5 points; within State Government’s Dependency, federal funding as a share of state revenue was given a full weight of 50 points.

Based on these calculations, New Mexico, at 86.57 points, ranked as the most federally dependent state overall and the state with the greatest resident dependency. Louisiana’s state government ranked the most dependent on the federal government. Kansas ranked least federally dependent overall, earning just 10.62 points. Delaware’s residents and Virginia’s state government were ranked least federally dependent of those categories.

Eight of the 10 most federally dependent states were Republican, while seven of the 10 least federally dependent states were Democratic, which suggests that overall Republican states are more dependent upon federal assistance than Democratic ones.

A+graphic+that+reveals+that+Democratic+states+are+less+dependent+on+federal+government+than+Republican+ones+with+pictures+of+political+party+donkey+and+elephant
Zoe Manzanetti



Additionally, when the amounts of contracts, grants and other financial assistance from the federal government that each state received were analyzed, those figures also supported the Republican dependency trend. The highest amounts of federal grants and other financial assistance were given to four of five Republican states in each category. Only two of the five states that received the most federal contracts voted Republican in the 2020 presidential election, but four of five of the states that received the least supported Joe Biden.

Not all experts agree on how the federal government should determine state allocations or whether some states should subsidize others.

“One of the roles of governments is to create an equitable society,” says Charles E. Menifield, dean of the School of Public Affairs and Administration at Rutgers University-Newark. “Equity is an outcome of a budget decision whether it is stated or unstated. Will the allocation assist a state (person) in improving the well-being of its residents?”



Source: WalletHub

But establishing equity is difficult when there is disagreement as to which programs should be a state and local responsibility and which should be a federal responsibility. Some experts, like Christopher Z. Mooney of the University of Illinois, Chicago, believes that the U.S. Constitution is very clear in its 10th Amendment, that as much should go to the states’ responsibilities as possible. But Miami University’s Mark Morris explains that however the distribution occurs, it will never be perfect and there will always be discrepancy.

“Fair does not mean equal,” he says. “We use a political process to make these decisions, so someone will always consider it unfair no matter what metric is used.”

Zoe is the web producer and a writer for Governing.
Special Projects
Sponsored Stories
Sponsored
Workplace safety is in the spotlight as government leaders adapt to a prolonged pandemic.
Sponsored
While government employees, students and the general public had to wait in line for hours in the beginning of the pandemic, at-home test kits make it easy to diagnose for the novel coronavirus in less than 30 minutes.
Sponsored
Governments around the nation are working to design the best vaccine policies that keep both their employees and their residents safe. Although the latest data shows a variety of polarizing perspectives, there are clear emerging best practices that leading governments are following to put trust first: creating policies that are flexible and provide a range of options, and being in tune with the needs and sentiments of their employees so that they are able to be dynamic and accommodate the rapidly changing situation.
Sponsored
Service delivery and the individual experience within health and human services (HHS) is often very siloed and fragmented.
Sponsored
In this episode, Marianne Steger explains why health care for Pre-Medicare retirees and active employees just got easier.
Sponsored
Government organizations around the world are experiencing the consequences of plagiarism firsthand. A simple mistake can lead to loss of reputation, loss of trust and even lawsuits. It’s important to avoid plagiarism at all costs, and government organizations are held to a particularly high standard. Fortunately, technological solutions such as iThenticate allow government organizations to avoid instances of text plagiarism in an efficient manner.
Sponsored
Creating meaningful citizen experiences in a post-COVID world requires embracing digital initiatives like secure and ethical data sharing, artificial intelligence and more.
Sponsored
GHD identified four themes critical for municipalities to address to reach net-zero by 2050. Will you be ready?
Sponsored
As more state and local jurisdictions have placed a priority on creating sustainable and resilient communities, many have set strong targets to reduce the energy use and greenhouse gases (GHGs) associated with commercial and residential buildings.