Internet Explorer 11 is not supported

For optimal browsing, we recommend Chrome, Firefox or Safari browsers.

Court Refuses to Reopen Teacher Tenure Case for Chris Christie

The New Jersey Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected an attempt by Gov. Christie to reopen the landmark Abbott v. Burke case that directed resources to urban school districts, denying his administration the power to freeze funding and break union contracts.

The New Jersey Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected an attempt by Gov. Christie to reopen the landmark Abbott v. Burke case that directed resources to urban school districts, denying his administration the power to freeze funding and break union contracts.

 

Christie had sought to override teacher tenure laws and collectively negotiated agreements in the former Abbott districts if the state determines those rules impede the delivery of a “thorough and efficient” education — as promised by the New Jersey Constitution.

 

That clause has underpinned the Abbott rulings, which required the state to send additional resources to special-needs districts.

 

But tenure laws and union agreements “have not been the subject of prior litigation” in the case, the court said in a two-page order Tuesday. It declined to take up those issues but said the Republican governor’s administration could pursue them at the trial court level.

 

Addressing reporters at a news conference Tuesday in Newark, Christie declined to comment on whether he would take the matter to a trial court, saying he hadn’t yet reviewed the Supreme Court order.

 

As he has in the past, the governor panned the court’s school-funding rulings, attributing the state school-funding formula to “seven people in black robes who have no business doing what they’ve done.”

Caroline Cournoyer is GOVERNING's senior web editor.