The Week in Public Finance: a $72 Billion Problem, Connecticut Transparency and Economic Malaise
A roundup of money (and other) news governments can use.
For past editions of the Week in Public Finance column, click here.
Puerto Rico trudges on
Puerto Rico and creditors started talks on July 14 this week regarding what would be an unprecedented debt restructuring deal for the municipal bond market outside of a Chapter 9 bankruptcy. But observers are reminding us there’s nothing to celebrate yet. For one, noted Municipal Market Analytics’ Matt Fabian, we could be years off from a solution on how to manage the territory’s $72 billion in obligations. Noting that trailing litigation can also endure for years, Fabian said in his weekly market analysis that “we are still in the early innings of Puerto Rico’s resolution.” And, much like happened with bankruptcy restructurings in Detroit and Stockton, Fabian expects recovery values to skew farther away from capital markets creditors and toward public employees and taxpayers. (In earlier Chapter 9 cases, the cities generally placed its pensioners before its other creditors when it came to paying their debts.)
Still, Fabian said, no debt restructuring can be considered complete without addressing the island’s $45 billion unfunded pension liability and additional $10 billion liability for retiree healthcare. “Many of Puerto Rico’s retirees reasonably still live on the island,” Fabian added, “implying an even greater incentive (than even in Detroit) to preserve all payments due to beneficiaries.”
Opening up the books (some more)
Connecticut took a step beyond the OpenCheckbook movement for which many states (including the Nutmeg State) have signed up and launched a new website that shows in real time how its budget is tracking through the year. Called “OpenBudget,” Comptroller Kevin Lembo’s new portal allows users to see how state spending and revenue compares against the state’s actual budgeted amounts throughout the year. Getting to see how spending is tracking provides a little more context than OpenCheckbook portals, which allow people to search and compare how much a government, agency or employee is spending on anything from office supplies to police officer salaries.
“OpenBudget is about destroying the barriers between the public and state government,” Lembo said at a press conference announcing the new website. "It's about opening the books, delivering timely financial information to the public, and giving everyone an opportunity to join the policy conversation.”
The Economic Innovation Group has been taking a look at the economic wellbeing of America’s communities and this week released its findings. The research organization broke down the data by zip code and looked at seven metrics:
1. Educational Attainment: Percent of population 25 years and over with a high school degree.
2. Housing Vacancy Rate: Percent of habitable housing that is unoccupied.
3. Unemployment Rate: Share of the labor force that is unemployed.
4. Poverty Level: Percent of population living under the poverty line.
5. Median Income Ratio: Ratio of the zip code’s median income to the state’s median income.
6. Change In Employment: Percent change in the number of individuals employed.
7. Change in Business Establishments: Percent change in the number of businesses.
The group listed the most distressed zip codes in each state and also ranked the states in terms of what percent of its population lives in a distressed zip code. Nevada easily tops the list with 33 percent of its population living in economic distress. The remaining top ten have between one-fifth and one-quarter of their residents living in economic distress and are located in the South or Southwest. States that have 4 percent or fewer residents living in distress zip codes are generally located in New England, the upper Midwest and Mountain West.
The results somewhat mirror findings last year by the National Association of Counties that most localities have not fully recovered from the recession. EIG also recently found in a survey of likely voters in presidential swing states that a significant portion of Americans still feel like the recovery has left them behind. “The [Distressed Communities Index] demonstrates that they don’t just feel it, they live it – over 30 million Americans to be exact – in communities defined by slow job growth, vanishing businesses, and fewer opportunities to move up the economic ladder,” EIG said.
States aren’t necessarily faring much better, even with their greater taxing power. An analysis by PNC’s Tom Kozlik this week concluded that U.S. state tax revenues are close to experiencing a “lost decade” – where overall tax revenue growth has been nonexistent. “This contrasts significantly with the last three recessions and partly helps to explain why: many state budgets are strained, some state credits have deteriorated...and why the public’s trust in government remains near an all-time low,” Kozlik wrote.