The Case for Appointments Over Special Elections
I, among many others, wondered in light of the Blagojevich scandal why we don't simply use special elections to fill all U.S. Senate ...
I, among many others, wondered in light of the Blagojevich scandal why we don't simply use special elections to fill all U.S. Senate vacancies -- as we do for all U.S. House vacancies. Joshua Spivak lays out the case for gubernatorial appointments in the Washington Post:
But there are hidden, and more fundamental, problems, too. Turnout for special elections is dramatically lower than it is for general elections. This shouldn't be a surprise -- voters have to care enough to come out for just one race, while on Election Day the presidency or a governorship may also be on the line. A perfect example was the recent Georgia runoff. This was a high-profile race, yet turnout was only a little more than half what it had been just 30 days before. Similarly, recall votes for state legislators, to cite one of the more regularly occurring special elections in the 18 states where they're allowed, typically attract a quarter to half as many voters as regular elections. Therefore winners are chosen by a seriously skewed electorate -- generally the most committed or more extreme members of each party.
A second problem involves primaries. Even in places that require special elections, there may be no requirement that parties hold primaries, giving party leaders a disproportionate role in making the selection. In states where one party dominates, that party's choice can be tantamount to an appointment. In New York, this method has been used and abused both for congressional representatives and state and local politicians. Sometimes, officials appear to time resignations in order to force a special election -- and ensure that a chosen successor has an easy path to victory.
We invite you to discuss and comment on this article using social media.
In the Elusive Search for Affordable Housing, Clues Emerge1 day ago
California Leaders Vow to Fight Trump's Oil Drilling Order Before It's Even Signed15 hours ago
State and Local Governments Express Concern About Trump's Tax Plan16 hours ago
If Trump Defunds 'Sanctuary Cities,’ Public Health Could Suffer16 hours ago
Purdue University's Unprecedented Move to Acquire a For-Profit College17 hours ago
Court: Employers Can Pay Women Less Than Men Based on Their Past Salaries17 hours ago