Comparing the House and Senate Versions of the DISCLOSE Act
Sunlight's Policy Counsel wrote about his curiosity regarding the differences between the House and Senate versions of the DISCLOSE Act, legislation that responds to the Supreme Court's campaign finance decision in Citizens United. Today, he has his answer.
This article was written by Daniel Schuman, the Sunlight Foundation's Policy Counsel.
Earlier this week I wrote about my curiosity regarding the differences between the House and Senate versions of the DISCLOSE Act, legislation that responds to the Supreme Court's campaign finance decision in Citizens United. Today, I have my answer.
Drawing upon THOMAS, Congress' online repository of its legislative information, I obtained XML versions of both documents and used Microsoft Word to compare the two. (For unknown reasons, although the House version has been available on THOMAS since last Friday, the Senate version only became available today.)
I have identified a handful of changes that go beyond style and organization:
The Senate version has findings relating to the rates that the media can charge for the purchase of advertisements, and rules implementing "lowest unit charge." (Sect. 401). Neither the findings nor rules exist in the House version.
• There are differences regarding the period of time during which the prohibitions on electioneering communications apply. (Sec. 202)
• The amounts of money triggering disclose of public independent disclosures are not the same. (Sec. 211)
• The Senate version requires Senate candidates to file their campaign reports with the FEC (Sec. 231). This is a rules change, and does not need to be in the House version.
There aren't a lot of changes, but I would have missed several of them in the 90-something page documents but for the legislation's online publication in a format that allows for easy comparison. Were they published only as PDFs, this task would have been much harder.
Still unexplained is why it took so long for THOMAS to make the Senate version of the DISCLOSE Act available in the first place.
Join the Discussion
After you comment, click Post. You can enter an anonymous Display Name or connect to a social profile.
Kentucky May Comply With EPA Regulations, Accidentally8 hours ago
Anti-Gay Marriage Bill Goes to North Carolina Governor's Desk8 hours ago
George Pataki, One of New York's Few Republican Governors, Runs for President10 hours ago
Underfunding of Research Offers States an Economic Opportunity11 hours ago
Motorcycle Lane-Splitting Could Soon Be Legal in California14 hours ago
Philadelphia School Official Accused of Giving $900,000 Contract to Associates14 hours ago